What does it mean to evaluate something? Well, the root of the word evaluation is "value," which, as it turns out, is a word with a variety of definitions depending on what is being evaluated.
One of this week's topics was the use of rubrics to evaluate student work. Before starting this class I had only a vague understanding of rubrics so as with many unfamiliar concepts, I approached this topic with some trepidation. However, the more I read about rubrics and the more I learned as I worked on creating my own rubric, the more I have come to appreciate their usefulness. Several of the referenced articles mentioned how parents really seem to like rubrics "once they understand how they are used." This, I think, is an important consideration because most parents are probably unfamiliar with rubrics and probably regard them like I did initially. So to evaluate a student's work using a rubric is simply to measure it's worth or degree of excellence compared to a carefully considered menu of pre-defined criteria. One way to define the criteria is to base it on previous student work on the same or similar assignments. Rubrics are useful for self-evaluation by the student, the other students in the class who participate in peer evaluations, parents who want to help their child with their work and teachers who can save time in grading the work. As a non-teacher, I can think of two ways I may be able to incorporate rubrics in my daily work; in assigning and evaluating projects given to staff or teachers and in employee performance evaluations.
The other topic I spent some time considering this week was evaluating hardware and software purchases. In this case, the value is more tangible in that you are looking at the features and benefits derived from a product or service in relation to the monetary cost of that item. Most people do this kind of evaluation all the time; at the grocery store, working on the family budget, making a major purchase, planning a vacation, etc. In my previous position, I had to evaluate the purchase of promotional items and advertising space. In my current job, I provided input on the purchase of laptop computers for student use taking into consideration things like, cost, reliability, features, security, longevity and liability. For example, Apple laptops were generally more reliable and had a longer useful lifespan, but we decided to buy 1,000 Compaq laptops instead because they were a third of the cost, more familiar for most students and more easily repaired. I also evaluate software and subscriptions to learning resources like Explore Learning Gizmos and United Streaming videos. I have the teachers who request these services provide justification for classroom applications then weigh the cost implications in the context of the school budget.
I do have to take issue with one of the web resources provided to learn about evaluating hardware and software. The article has an intriguing title, "How To Buy An Educational Software In Sixty Seconds Or Less," but that turned out to be misleading. I was hoping for something that would help simplify the process, but what I got was cursory dose of low-level, and sometimes contradictory advice. On the on hand, the author says to make sure the software is fun and entertaining while later on he cautions that if the graphics are too flashy, they can be distracting to students. He also says that using educational software should be effortless. I disagree. I think teachers should put as much thought and effort into choosing education software as they do selecting any other resource and maybe even more because we all know that technology should only be used if there is a clearly identified educational purpose.
Reflections on my experience in the online Master of Education in Instructional Technology program at Cardinal Stritch University in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. My cohort started the program in fall of 2010 and I expect to complete my degree in spring of 2012.
Tuesday, July 12, 2011
Sunday, July 10, 2011
Presentations and Digital Stories
There are some interesting similarities and contrasts between Garr Reynolds approach to presentations and Bernajean Porter's take on digital storytelling. Both emphasize the importance of using images to help tell the story and both spend a considerable amount of time discussing how to obtain, manipulate, edit and position images for greatest impact. This is an interesting approach since traditionally, both presentations and stories relied much more heavily on words than images - the printed or spoken word in stories and the much maligned bullet-point lists so often found in presentations.
Prezi fits nicely into this new way of telling stories because of it's very visual, non-linear approach to presentations - although the zooming nature of Prezi can fly in the face of the simpler, zen-like style advocated by Reynolds. I have seen some Prezis that overdo the zooming to the point beyond distraction to bordering on seasickness.
The other element both authors emphasize is the spoken narrative. Both talk about the importance of delivering the narrative in a natural way, as opposed to reading a script. Reynolds focuses more on the "naturalness" when presenting live while Porter describes how a digital storyteller can use their vocal performance tools (pauses, inflection, etc.) to help tell their story.
The combination of high-quality, carefully selected images combined with a well-planned, purposefully created narrative and tempered with restraint, simplicity and creative design makes for powerful communication instruments in the form of more engaging presentations and entertaining digital stories.
Prezi fits nicely into this new way of telling stories because of it's very visual, non-linear approach to presentations - although the zooming nature of Prezi can fly in the face of the simpler, zen-like style advocated by Reynolds. I have seen some Prezis that overdo the zooming to the point beyond distraction to bordering on seasickness.
The other element both authors emphasize is the spoken narrative. Both talk about the importance of delivering the narrative in a natural way, as opposed to reading a script. Reynolds focuses more on the "naturalness" when presenting live while Porter describes how a digital storyteller can use their vocal performance tools (pauses, inflection, etc.) to help tell their story.
The combination of high-quality, carefully selected images combined with a well-planned, purposefully created narrative and tempered with restraint, simplicity and creative design makes for powerful communication instruments in the form of more engaging presentations and entertaining digital stories.
Friday, June 24, 2011
Presentation Polarization: Is There A Right And Wrong Way To Use PowerPoint?
If there is one thing we can all agree on, it's that America is becoming more polarized. Public/private, conservative/liberal, the haves and the have nots. We see it clearly in politics where there doesn't seem to be any middle ground any more. The same seems to be happening among digital presenters. I'll call the two camps "conventional" (those who use templates, bullet points, graphs and charts and hand out copies of their slides at the beginning of the presentation) and "contemporary" (no templates, lots of images, few words and a separate handout of the supporting data at the end of the presentation). I propose that in the battle for digital dominance, the two sides can, and should, coexist.
I participate in at least 2-3 meetings a week (some in person but most via web conference) and most of those meetings involve one or more slide presentations. Almost all of those slides are designed in the conventional way (i.e. Title, bullet points, charts, graphs, clipart). And you know what? They generally get the job done. I get the information I need. Are they exciting? Usually not. Are they memorable? Not particularly. Are they informative? Yes. Do they take the presenter an inordinate amount of time to create? No. Those last two points are important considerations in the corporate world. Plus, conventional PowerPoints transmit well online and are small enough files that they can be emailed to people who were not able to attend the meeting.
Now I 'm not suggesting that there is no room for improvement in the world of corporate presentations. But I do think that the principles discussed by Garr Reynolds in Presentation Zen are just not necessary or practical in every situation. If you are presenting at a conference, to a potential new business client, to make a sale or even in the classroom, a more contemporary presentation along with an accompanying handout that is not merely a printout of the slides is likely to be more effective. And in those situations, I agree entirely with Reynolds' suggestions. However, I disagree with the extremists who want to criminalize the use of PowerPoint templates and administer electric shocks through the mouse of anyone who dares to hover over the bullet point toolbar. As with most issues, there is a middle ground. Conventional PowerPoint templates are still useful and appropriate for the day-to-day business meeting.
Having said that, I found the process of taking one of my more conventional PowerPoint presentations and applying some contemporary elements to be very enlightening. Since this presentation was designed for a student and parent instructional setting, not a corporate business meeting, I think the contemporary approach is more appropriate. To that end, I eliminated much of the text, added some more graphic elements and completely revised the accompanying handout. Here's an example of the changes I made:
As you can see, the original slide has a distracting and unnecessary background and contains no less than 11 bullet points. It also has inconsistent fonts and colors. This information should be mentioned by the presenter and included in the handout.
The revised slide is simplified and much more visually engaging. It uses a high-quality image and a simple title that is direct and to the point. The font and color of the text is consistent with the other revised slides which incorporates the principle of repetition.
The bottom line is I will be using the Presentation Zen concepts, but not in every situation. Future presentations to students and families or at conferences will be more contemporary, but I suspect my presentations to teachers about new procedures for using the Online Enrollment System will look very much the same as they always have.
I participate in at least 2-3 meetings a week (some in person but most via web conference) and most of those meetings involve one or more slide presentations. Almost all of those slides are designed in the conventional way (i.e. Title, bullet points, charts, graphs, clipart). And you know what? They generally get the job done. I get the information I need. Are they exciting? Usually not. Are they memorable? Not particularly. Are they informative? Yes. Do they take the presenter an inordinate amount of time to create? No. Those last two points are important considerations in the corporate world. Plus, conventional PowerPoints transmit well online and are small enough files that they can be emailed to people who were not able to attend the meeting.
Now I 'm not suggesting that there is no room for improvement in the world of corporate presentations. But I do think that the principles discussed by Garr Reynolds in Presentation Zen are just not necessary or practical in every situation. If you are presenting at a conference, to a potential new business client, to make a sale or even in the classroom, a more contemporary presentation along with an accompanying handout that is not merely a printout of the slides is likely to be more effective. And in those situations, I agree entirely with Reynolds' suggestions. However, I disagree with the extremists who want to criminalize the use of PowerPoint templates and administer electric shocks through the mouse of anyone who dares to hover over the bullet point toolbar. As with most issues, there is a middle ground. Conventional PowerPoint templates are still useful and appropriate for the day-to-day business meeting.
Having said that, I found the process of taking one of my more conventional PowerPoint presentations and applying some contemporary elements to be very enlightening. Since this presentation was designed for a student and parent instructional setting, not a corporate business meeting, I think the contemporary approach is more appropriate. To that end, I eliminated much of the text, added some more graphic elements and completely revised the accompanying handout. Here's an example of the changes I made:
![]() |
| Before |
![]() | |
| After |
As you can see, the original slide has a distracting and unnecessary background and contains no less than 11 bullet points. It also has inconsistent fonts and colors. This information should be mentioned by the presenter and included in the handout.
The revised slide is simplified and much more visually engaging. It uses a high-quality image and a simple title that is direct and to the point. The font and color of the text is consistent with the other revised slides which incorporates the principle of repetition.
The bottom line is I will be using the Presentation Zen concepts, but not in every situation. Future presentations to students and families or at conferences will be more contemporary, but I suspect my presentations to teachers about new procedures for using the Online Enrollment System will look very much the same as they always have.
Monday, June 6, 2011
Same Story, Different Medium
I've always enjoyed a good story and I've always been intrigued by new technology so this foray into the world of digital storytelling has been a fascinating experience so far.
I particularly liked the collection of digital stories from Next Exit Digital Drive. The storyteller does a nice job of incorporating digital tools without losing track of the elements that make for a good story. And I believe that is the key. Just like in the visual arts, the medium should never detract from the message. Rather, it should complement and enhance the message.
Finding that balance will be a challenge for teachers trying to use digital storytelling with their class. It would be very easy for students to get caught up in using video, audio and other graphic tools and lose sight of the elements of good storytelling.
The elements of good storytelling and good, or at least better, presentations are things that make them "sticky" according to this week's reading from Garr Reynold's Presentation Zen. I think the "stickiness" concepts of concreteness, credibility, simplicity, emotion and unexpectedness apply equally to stories and presentations.
I can envision using digital stories in my role as marketing manager for iQ Academy. One of our biggest challenges is communicating the value of virtual schools to families who in many cases have never been exposed to anything other than traditional public education. To that end, digital stories told by students, parents and teachers could be particularly valuable. They are also easy to distribute to prospective families via email or posted on our website.
I particularly liked the collection of digital stories from Next Exit Digital Drive. The storyteller does a nice job of incorporating digital tools without losing track of the elements that make for a good story. And I believe that is the key. Just like in the visual arts, the medium should never detract from the message. Rather, it should complement and enhance the message.
Finding that balance will be a challenge for teachers trying to use digital storytelling with their class. It would be very easy for students to get caught up in using video, audio and other graphic tools and lose sight of the elements of good storytelling.
The elements of good storytelling and good, or at least better, presentations are things that make them "sticky" according to this week's reading from Garr Reynold's Presentation Zen. I think the "stickiness" concepts of concreteness, credibility, simplicity, emotion and unexpectedness apply equally to stories and presentations.
I can envision using digital stories in my role as marketing manager for iQ Academy. One of our biggest challenges is communicating the value of virtual schools to families who in many cases have never been exposed to anything other than traditional public education. To that end, digital stories told by students, parents and teachers could be particularly valuable. They are also easy to distribute to prospective families via email or posted on our website.
Monday, May 9, 2011
Digital Storytelling
As a young broadcast journalism student, I was taught that news reporting is really a form of storytelling, and that the basic elements of every story are who, what, when, where, why and how. Translated into conventional story telling jargon, that would be characters, plot, setting and motivation. Whether in news or fiction (some would ask, "What's the difference?"), you need all of those elements to tell a good story. But what if you are not satisfied with telling a "good" story? What if you want to tell a "great" story?
For the answer to that question, I turn to a master story-teller, my former pastor, the late Fr. Dave Meinholz. Fr. Dave would always reach a point in his sermons where he would pause and ask, "So What?" In other words, we understand the basic elements of the story, but how does it affect us? How does it impact our life? Why do we care? Adding this element turns a good story into a great story.
Digital storytelling, then, is the art of telling great stories combined with the science of using digital tools. I have done a fair amount of storytelling during my years in the newsroom and working in public relations and marketing, and I have learned quite a bit about using digital tools, but I have not had a lot of opportunities to combine the two. I am looking forward to being able to tell great digital stories to my current and prospective students as well as my colleagues, friends and family.
For the answer to that question, I turn to a master story-teller, my former pastor, the late Fr. Dave Meinholz. Fr. Dave would always reach a point in his sermons where he would pause and ask, "So What?" In other words, we understand the basic elements of the story, but how does it affect us? How does it impact our life? Why do we care? Adding this element turns a good story into a great story.
Digital storytelling, then, is the art of telling great stories combined with the science of using digital tools. I have done a fair amount of storytelling during my years in the newsroom and working in public relations and marketing, and I have learned quite a bit about using digital tools, but I have not had a lot of opportunities to combine the two. I am looking forward to being able to tell great digital stories to my current and prospective students as well as my colleagues, friends and family.
Thursday, April 21, 2011
More than Words... Applying What I Learned in Enhancing Learning Materials Through Technology
Pick a cliche, "Put up or shut up," "Actions speak louder than words," "Walk the walk," "Put your money where your mouth is," "Do or do not, there is no try." OK, that last one may just be an antiquated Star Wars reference, but you get the idea. After five weeks of studying ways to integrate technology to enhance proven learning strategies, it was finally time to apply that conceptual knowledge to evaluate and improve an actual class lesson. This was a daunting task for someone like myself who has never developed a classroom lesson plan before, let alone a good one that incorporates sound learning theory supported by technology. However, emboldened by the support of my small group members, I felt I was up for the challenge.
I used the only lesson-type presentation I have developed myself - an orientation session for students participating in the Test Drive iQ Academy program. You can view my presentation at https://docs.google.com/present/edit?id=0AbU9x8j6YWIgZGQyNnpxbTRfMThjNHg1NWh0&hl=en&authkey=CJCBu3M
I used the only lesson-type presentation I have developed myself - an orientation session for students participating in the Test Drive iQ Academy program. You can view my presentation at https://docs.google.com/present/edit?id=0AbU9x8j6YWIgZGQyNnpxbTRfMThjNHg1NWh0&hl=en&authkey=CJCBu3MSo what did I learn from this exercise? Quite a lot actually. Throughout this class we have demonstrated that incorporating technology to support proven learning strategies can greatly enhance student achievement. To that end, this should be happening for every lesson in every classroom in America. What I found out is that enhancing learning materials through technology is really not all that difficult - at least in theory. If I can do it, anyone can. The realities of classroom practice may present some additional challenges, but the effort required to overcome those challenges is certainly worthwhile.
Related to that point is the realization that many teachers could do the same thing to their lessons if they knew how, which brings me to the real revelation I experienced by taking this class - that I want to help facilitate this transformation. I will start with the teachers at my school. I may have to spend some time in the classroom (physical or virtual) myself to fully comprehend the situation. But somehow, some way I want to help bring the American education system kicking and screaming into the 21st century. To do anything less would be a disservice to the next generation.
This class has really motivated me to do some more research and study of technology enhanced learning. A recent federal government report on technology in education points out that, "The challenge for our education system is to leverage the learning sciences and modern technology to create energizing, relevant, and personalized learning experiences for all learners that mirror students’ daily lives and the reality of their futures.” One really interesting concept I came across was the "flipped classroom" (see http://youtu.be/2H4RkudFzlc). The concept is simply that the teacher assigns the traditional lecture as homework and has the student do homework (or projects, or group work) during class time. The lectures are presented as podcasts that student can watch online or on a mobile device. The benefit is that the teacher can spend more time working with students individually and the students are more engaged.
Another fascinating example is the Kahn Academy which the founder explains in Salman Khan: Let's use video to reinvent education Video on TED.com. He basically created thousands of free videos that explain individual lessons in math, science, economics and various other subjects. Then he developed a self paced, interactive program to teach the concepts online. If a student gets stuck, they link to the respective video for help. When they master 10 questions about the topic in a row, they can move on the the next one.
Both of these revolutionary ideas were developed within the past 5 years and made possible by technology. Imagine what we will be able to do 10 years from now? I want to be a part of that.
Wednesday, April 13, 2011
Changing the Odds for Student Success (and other Week 5 CEDO 525 stuff)
When I was 18-years old and trying to decide what I was going to be when I grew up, my parents pulled me aside and told me, "Son, you can do whatever you want to do, just don't be a teacher." Want to venture a guess as to what they did for a living? You got it, they were both public school teachers. Don't get me wrong, they both loved teaching, they just knew all too well how difficult the profession had become (even 30-years ago) and they figured I had to be able to find an easier way to make a living.
I mention that story because I recently finished reading Using Technology With Classroom Instruction That Works by Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn and Malenoski, and I can't help but wonder if I received some well-intentioned, but misleading advice. All the learning strategies in this book make perfect sense to me and I am mystified that every teacher in America is not making a conscious effort to apply these principles in every class they teach.
Some thoughts about the last three learning strategies:
Identifying Similarities and Differences
Crucial for connecting prior knowledge and for broader understanding of concepts in context. Can be either teacher directed or student-directed. Technology supported diagrams and graphic representations are particularly effective in this exercise.
Homework and Practice
Homework can't just be busy work - it must have a clearly defined and communicated purpose and relation to the learning targets. Allows students to extend their learning outside the classroom. Use of web-based resources is helpful because they can be accessed both in and out of the classroom.
Generating and Testing Hypotheses
Not just for science, this strategy really speaks to accessing those all-important higher order thinking skills. Students should be able to explain their hypothesis and what evidence they use to test it. Computer-based simulations are a great way to test hypotheses because it is relatively inexpensive and students get immediate feedback.
I mention that story because I recently finished reading Using Technology With Classroom Instruction That Works by Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn and Malenoski, and I can't help but wonder if I received some well-intentioned, but misleading advice. All the learning strategies in this book make perfect sense to me and I am mystified that every teacher in America is not making a conscious effort to apply these principles in every class they teach.
Some thoughts about the last three learning strategies:
Identifying Similarities and Differences
Crucial for connecting prior knowledge and for broader understanding of concepts in context. Can be either teacher directed or student-directed. Technology supported diagrams and graphic representations are particularly effective in this exercise.
Homework and Practice
Homework can't just be busy work - it must have a clearly defined and communicated purpose and relation to the learning targets. Allows students to extend their learning outside the classroom. Use of web-based resources is helpful because they can be accessed both in and out of the classroom.
Generating and Testing Hypotheses
Not just for science, this strategy really speaks to accessing those all-important higher order thinking skills. Students should be able to explain their hypothesis and what evidence they use to test it. Computer-based simulations are a great way to test hypotheses because it is relatively inexpensive and students get immediate feedback.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

